The impossibly soft bunny that becomes the bunny — the one packed for every trip. Get a backup. You'll want a backup.
Shop at Jellycat →
The swaddle other swaddles get compared to. Softens with every wash. If you buy one thing off this list, it's these. For a newborn for a baby shower, it's the one I'd actually buy.
The impossibly soft bunny that becomes the bunny — the one packed for every trip. Get a backup. You'll want a backup.
Shop at Jellycat →
A quiet cool-mist humidifier you don't mind seeing on the shelf. Small comfort that earns its keep all winter long.
Shop at Crane →
Big, breathable, and prints you won't be sick of by month three. Doubles as a nursing cover and a stroller shade.
Shop at Little Unicorn →
High-contrast black-white-red — the only colors a newborn actually sees. The rare mobile that's for the baby, not the shelf.
Shop at Manhattan Toy →
It's the satin tags they love, not the blanket. A five-dollar idea that becomes the most important object in the house.
Shop at Mary Meyer →
A crib sheet soft enough that the nursery finally looks like the nursery in your head. Buy two — laundry happens at 2am.
Shop at Crane Baby →
The bath that grows through the slippery-newborn stage into sitting-up baths. One tub, not three.
Shop at Skip Hop →
The teether every nursery ends up owning. Soft, squeaky, exactly the right size for a fist that can't hold much yet.
Shop at Sophie la Girafe →
Buttery organic cotton at a real price. The everyday layer you're not precious about — which is the point with a newborn.
Shop at Burt's Bees Baby →
Drool bibs that read as an outfit, not a spill rag. You'll want the four-pack — trust me.
Shop at Copper Pearl →
Pacifier sewn into a little animal so it stops disappearing into the car seat. The one thing that actually stayed found in my house.
Shop at WubbaNub →Little Lamb earns a commission when you buy through our links — at no cost to you. We take no sponsored placements; every pick is chosen the way I'd choose for my own grandkids. —Rebecca Full disclosure →