Mary Arnold Toys
New York City's Original Family TOY STORE Since 1931
Mary Arnold Toys keeps a shop on Lexington Avenue on the Upper East Side, and calls itself New York City's original family toy store — in business since 1931. It is a toy store rather than a clothing boutique, and it opens seven days a week, with a shorter Sunday.
It is the only shop this guide lists above 79th Street on the east side, which makes it the natural stop if you are uptown and need a present today.
Is this your shop?
Claim your listing — free, always — to keep the details right, tell your story in your own words, and add your own photographs. And if you'd like a shop website that feels like this page, that's something we can build too.
No cost to claim. No obligation. Listings are hand-checked and never paid placements.